Can’t recommend Island Car Care enough. I was driving from Brooklyn to Staten Island recovering from surgery when my check engine, brake, and low oil lights all lit up at once — clear signs that pushing any further would cause serious engine damage. I pulled into Island Car Care because it’s the closest shop I trust, and I’m so glad I did. From the moment I walked in, the team was friendly and welcoming. They quickly diagnosed the issue as a broken, leaking radiator. While my car was in their care, they also took care of some front suspension problems — a bent and rotted subframe — and used only quality parts for the repairs. What really stood out was their honesty: they didn’t try to upsell me on anything I didn’t need, and they kept pricing on parts and labor fair and affordable. My car now runs smoothly with no issues. What made me most confident I was in the right place was a beautiful image of Jesus displayed in the shop, and the owner sharing that he lives by the golden rule — “do unto others as you would have them do unto you.” You could tell right away these were good, honest people who genuinely care about their customers. Truly thankful for their service. If you need an auto shop you can trust, this is the one.